Manipur is withering away day in and day out. The continuous ethnic conflicts, bandhs, blockades, warfare among the so-called self-proclaimed revolutionaries and the security forces, have skinned Manipur to such an extent that the future is covered with a black cloak. War, violence, guns, drugs etc have glorified our society. We are going through desensitization and over the generation, it has become a vicious cycle. Our present situation is similar to that of a frog that jumped into a well and declared himself the Suzerain of the Universe.
Our hearts are filled with egregious self-deception which is covered by the garb of pretended humanity. So far, all that we have attempted is the reduction of life, one’s being and feelings just for the sake of our own survival. This reduction that I am talking of, may not limit itself to simply what I have pointed out. It comes in different guises and is known by many names. Whether it is the domestication of the wild, measuring or quantifying nature, conversion of culture, society or spirituality, all comes under the umbrella of reduction. And it is very often accompanied by violence.
This crescendo of violence has always seeped into thousands of generations and has feverishly bled our civilization for uncountable years. From the weeding of fields to the coercion of children to the elimination of enemies in the name of territorial security, violence has been cultivated and controlled in our society as it is required inherently. Violence seems not to be violence when it is only a weed, only an animal, only a savage, only an enemy or only a thing (Quoting Charles Eisenstein). Competing for survival, objectifying others being and conceptualizing ourselves as a separate being in itself, leads to legitimizing violence against others.
The social crisis that we are going through at the moment is not due to selfishness or greed alone. It is due to the ‘Mentality of Scarcity’, which encourages us to ‘Hoard and Accumulate’, ‘Possess and Own’! So the solution of the problem does not rest in to make do with less or to sacrifice our best benefits but in getting rid of the mentality.
Secondly, the attempt to categorize culture, differentiating it from the good and the bad, only emphasizes on the actions of individual gains which often leads to harming others in a community. So without a proper substructure, trying to bring forth new social forms of reinforcement is next to impossible. We have become even more confused than we have ever been. Our culture is engulfed in the spectrum of rational self interest. The ravages of our culture in the name of security, ease, and control have created untold misery in the State.
Not only is life at the summit of success disgracefully devoid of intimacy, community, authenticity and meaning, but even the security and control to which these have been sacrificed is a sham. For the sake of security we have shut off real living, and in return have received not even security but only a temporary semblance of it. Trying to repeal the surge of devastation that has swallowed up our living space, our society, our communities, and our psyches, require more than trying to be nice or wearing a facade of humanity.
Conflicts and counter-conflicts in Manipur is a usual occurrence with no authority to control over it. And the State Government is busy rolling up their cuffs doing nothing to preside over the trouble torn situation. The challenges that the State faces today is multi-dimensional. And the question that arises is how the people and its Government will solve the issues in the year that follows. We must put in collective efforts to resist against the divisive and dubious forces that are trying to gain its momentum on our society. We should continue to strive and uphold the glory and cultural identity that we have inherited from our ancestors.
Great aspirations and truth is a two edge weapon which produces stunning acts of love and overwhelming mayhem revealing the character of its wielder. Some might even conclude saying that war (irrespective of communal or national) is something that none of us want but often driven by necessity. But doesn’t this mean we are on a wild goose chase, running after a mirage, an aggrandizement of a narrow self that doesn’t actually exist?
The chances of humanity changing might be dim at present, but getting those few people who understands and can find the good in their hearts and foster it, in the forefront, will be worth it. Throughout the generation, over the last couple of years, we have been repeatedly making the mistakes over and over again. And this is because we have the same people in power; the same dreadful, ignorant, despicable people still have the authority. Yet it doesn’t negate the chances of achieving peace in our state. It may sound like a dream for the time being but even if it does it is a dream worth dreaming for the day will come if not sooner than later!
The article was published on The Sangai Express on Friday, the 20th of January 2012
Labels:
Article
Education - An Important Tool For Social Change
Education plays a key role in making the society go through a makeover reasonably and coherently. The unprecedented social, economic and ecological crises that we are going through right now are the result of the attempt to create and reproduce order, to create obedience to authority and to create compliant students. The education that we get today is not an education at all. It is best identified as a training which moulds the young mind to re-structure and reinforce the age old hierarchy and domination that affects the society. It has nothing much to do with unfolding the potential of an individual. It is rather a training that prepares the young mind to become a part of the so-called “productive” members without questioning and carry on the legacy!
However, at the moment what we require is a transformation of the system to get rid of the deep-rooted evils which limits the capability of the youths to only reading, writing and calculating mechanically. All that we are taught throughout our entire life is how to obey the authority, respond to the bells and whistles and never question the authority of power. No doubt these are things that have been extremely useful in our lives but there are also many other things beyond this that instigate us consciously or unconsciously to accept without questioning which have resulted in the devastating effect on the society. Wave after wave of reforms have been largely driven as per the demands of the society but because of the reproduction of the hierarchy (as it has been the sole power for the society to protect itself for its own survival), change was no where near visible.
The ideas of a meaningful social change have always been fostered but because of the belief in anarchism, materializing the change has always been a far cry. A radical education instead of the traditional education system is the call of the hour. But the question is how do we bring about it? A clear and proper understanding of the traditional system of education will be successful in manifesting radical education. Recognizing the evils that have been plaguing the society is the first step of improving education. Just as Jerry Mintz have pointed out,
“…there are oases around the world, there is a free-school here or a free-school there. But in general these noble experiments are isolated and the number of children that they reach is extremely limited. And that’s very unfortunate, because at this formative stage in children’s development the most valuable thing that we can offer them is freedom to explore, and resources they can use in that exploration. But this is not something that figures largely in the scheme of traditional education at all.”
The current scenario represents an economic ladder that has been stigmatized as failures and blamed for the condition. We are living in a society where reform means denying the privileges of the common people, a society which promotes the need for instant gratification and those who do not fit the bill are shunned. Though we live in a democratic country but the idea of democracy which involves individual rights, social responsibility, collective decision-making and shared social goals, is lost amidst the chaos. To mend all these, the need to develop an educational process which encourages freedom, free-for-all development, etc is required. This will expose the future generation to ideas, concepts and critical understanding of the myths to deconstruct and reinstate it with something optimistic and constructive.
The ideas of Philosophers like Dewey, Freire, Greene, Horton, and Banks manifest that, “society is always changing and knowledge is not neutral—it either supports the status quo or a potential new direction for society; people learn primarily from what they experience; active citizens in a democratic society need to be critical and imaginative thinkers; and students learn to be active citizens by being active citizens.”
Mahathir Muhammad, who ruled Malaysia for 21 years, focusing on socializing people through education, is a perfect example to quote. Though he ruled the country in the form of dictatorship but his educational policies are remarkable. Malaysia which was left far behind from the realm of education and economic development changed its destiny after exposure to qualitative education for two generations. The country was changed from agriculture to industrialization. And this simply proves the fact that Education indeed is the best tool to change destiny of our state. So instead of oppressing and suppressing our youths, it would be wise to encourage them to think critically and independently, question the authority, participate as active agents of social change. It is high time we understand that education should not be limited to classrooms only but should go beyond it to make the students understand their social responsibility as education can only bring about a social change.
The Article was published on the Sangai Express on Friday, 13th of January 2012
However, at the moment what we require is a transformation of the system to get rid of the deep-rooted evils which limits the capability of the youths to only reading, writing and calculating mechanically. All that we are taught throughout our entire life is how to obey the authority, respond to the bells and whistles and never question the authority of power. No doubt these are things that have been extremely useful in our lives but there are also many other things beyond this that instigate us consciously or unconsciously to accept without questioning which have resulted in the devastating effect on the society. Wave after wave of reforms have been largely driven as per the demands of the society but because of the reproduction of the hierarchy (as it has been the sole power for the society to protect itself for its own survival), change was no where near visible.
The ideas of a meaningful social change have always been fostered but because of the belief in anarchism, materializing the change has always been a far cry. A radical education instead of the traditional education system is the call of the hour. But the question is how do we bring about it? A clear and proper understanding of the traditional system of education will be successful in manifesting radical education. Recognizing the evils that have been plaguing the society is the first step of improving education. Just as Jerry Mintz have pointed out,
“…there are oases around the world, there is a free-school here or a free-school there. But in general these noble experiments are isolated and the number of children that they reach is extremely limited. And that’s very unfortunate, because at this formative stage in children’s development the most valuable thing that we can offer them is freedom to explore, and resources they can use in that exploration. But this is not something that figures largely in the scheme of traditional education at all.”
The current scenario represents an economic ladder that has been stigmatized as failures and blamed for the condition. We are living in a society where reform means denying the privileges of the common people, a society which promotes the need for instant gratification and those who do not fit the bill are shunned. Though we live in a democratic country but the idea of democracy which involves individual rights, social responsibility, collective decision-making and shared social goals, is lost amidst the chaos. To mend all these, the need to develop an educational process which encourages freedom, free-for-all development, etc is required. This will expose the future generation to ideas, concepts and critical understanding of the myths to deconstruct and reinstate it with something optimistic and constructive.
The ideas of Philosophers like Dewey, Freire, Greene, Horton, and Banks manifest that, “society is always changing and knowledge is not neutral—it either supports the status quo or a potential new direction for society; people learn primarily from what they experience; active citizens in a democratic society need to be critical and imaginative thinkers; and students learn to be active citizens by being active citizens.”
Mahathir Muhammad, who ruled Malaysia for 21 years, focusing on socializing people through education, is a perfect example to quote. Though he ruled the country in the form of dictatorship but his educational policies are remarkable. Malaysia which was left far behind from the realm of education and economic development changed its destiny after exposure to qualitative education for two generations. The country was changed from agriculture to industrialization. And this simply proves the fact that Education indeed is the best tool to change destiny of our state. So instead of oppressing and suppressing our youths, it would be wise to encourage them to think critically and independently, question the authority, participate as active agents of social change. It is high time we understand that education should not be limited to classrooms only but should go beyond it to make the students understand their social responsibility as education can only bring about a social change.
The Article was published on the Sangai Express on Friday, 13th of January 2012
Labels:
Article
Terrorism Or Revolution In Manipur
‘Terrorism or Revolution’ what should we refer to what has been going on in Manipur? Every other day reports on a grenade being hurled to the residence or office of so and so, XYZ people killed etc covers the news channel and the news papers. In the name of liberation, freedom, autonomy and sovereignty, our rights as a human being, our right to live, have been suppressed. In the name of revolution, terrorism is being spread throughout the state. The media which have a great role to play in the development and upliftment of the society and the state as a whole are kept busy with issues such as these. If you say you are terrorizing the people for a cause then for whom are you fighting the cause?
Killing everyone who raises their voice against you, threatening those who refuse to submit, hurling grenades at the homes of those who refuses to meet your demands, which of these acts identifies revolution? How long are we expected to struggle yet tolerate oppression, suppression and repression? The three words clearly signify the situation of Manipur and the plight of the common people. On one hand are the corrupt politicians who, at every possible and available opportunity, try to oppress us. On the other hand are, our so called liberators who suppress and repress us with terror and fright.
There are two sides of everything, the good and the bad. Besides the clear cut demarcation between the good and the bad, there is a middle path which is often referred to as the socially acceptable irrespective of whether it is good or bad. Do you think the atrocious acts are socially acceptable? The killing of Irom Roger and leaving the killer scot-free, the killing of the father-son duo and the recent incident where grenade was left in a press, how do you identify this as an act of revolution? Recounting the happenings and incidents that have been taking place in our state, I would say nearly all such deeds are no where near humane forget about being socially acceptable.
Very few people understand the actual difference between revolution and terrorism. There have been several instances where revolutionaries have been regarded as a terrorist. It is actually the actions and deeds that identify one from the other. Some of you might argue saying that to achieve the goal for the cause a revolution makes use of terrorism. Then you must also have this clarity in mind that revolutionists do not resort to commit violence against the people and do not forcibly try to change the mentality of the people. They try to bring over a change by reasoning, convincing through their actions and thoughts. Destroying properties, killing people for no reasons, is not a revolution. It is terrorism. One cannot simply force down one’s ideologies on others. If one is true to the cause and is a true revolutionary then one would respect the people at large and thus would make an effort to make the state a better place to live in instead of resorting to coercion, homicide and destruction.
The activities going on in the state is a complete contradiction of the ideas of Revolution. The beautiful view of revolution and its glory has been nullified with the acts of terrorism being committed in the name of revolution. I wonder if there is any difference between once Taliban ruled Afghanistan and the Manipur of today. The state has been in turmoil with a complete breakdown in law and order. Instability is the word synonymous to Manipur now. If the idea of liberation is to add to the prevalent upheaval of the state, to disturb the peace of the state, rather than solving the issues and moving towards development then we do not want liberation. We want a place to live in peace and in unison. We are tired of the uncertainty we are in. It is a pity that at the end of the day we find ourselves fighting amongst ourselves for survival.
Everywhere in the country, media enjoys the widely known Freedom of the Press which no one can overrule but in Manipur, media is no longer an autonomous entity. Voicing one’s opinion is more or less like asking for trouble. The people of the state are rotting of poverty, corruption, lack of education, unemployment, etc. What is the use of liberation in such a scenario? When such questions are being posed, the only answer one have is we have rich cultural heritage, we excel in sports, etc… etc. But the rich cultural heritage that we keep bragging about is a thing of the past now. We stand no where near development. And this is an attribution of the brain drain that has been occurring due to the instability of the state, slowing down in the progress of the state. The world, at large, has already gone way up beyond development. And here we are still struggling with Terrorism/Revolution!
The Article was published in Sangai Express on Sunday, 8th January 2012
Killing everyone who raises their voice against you, threatening those who refuse to submit, hurling grenades at the homes of those who refuses to meet your demands, which of these acts identifies revolution? How long are we expected to struggle yet tolerate oppression, suppression and repression? The three words clearly signify the situation of Manipur and the plight of the common people. On one hand are the corrupt politicians who, at every possible and available opportunity, try to oppress us. On the other hand are, our so called liberators who suppress and repress us with terror and fright.
There are two sides of everything, the good and the bad. Besides the clear cut demarcation between the good and the bad, there is a middle path which is often referred to as the socially acceptable irrespective of whether it is good or bad. Do you think the atrocious acts are socially acceptable? The killing of Irom Roger and leaving the killer scot-free, the killing of the father-son duo and the recent incident where grenade was left in a press, how do you identify this as an act of revolution? Recounting the happenings and incidents that have been taking place in our state, I would say nearly all such deeds are no where near humane forget about being socially acceptable.
Very few people understand the actual difference between revolution and terrorism. There have been several instances where revolutionaries have been regarded as a terrorist. It is actually the actions and deeds that identify one from the other. Some of you might argue saying that to achieve the goal for the cause a revolution makes use of terrorism. Then you must also have this clarity in mind that revolutionists do not resort to commit violence against the people and do not forcibly try to change the mentality of the people. They try to bring over a change by reasoning, convincing through their actions and thoughts. Destroying properties, killing people for no reasons, is not a revolution. It is terrorism. One cannot simply force down one’s ideologies on others. If one is true to the cause and is a true revolutionary then one would respect the people at large and thus would make an effort to make the state a better place to live in instead of resorting to coercion, homicide and destruction.
The activities going on in the state is a complete contradiction of the ideas of Revolution. The beautiful view of revolution and its glory has been nullified with the acts of terrorism being committed in the name of revolution. I wonder if there is any difference between once Taliban ruled Afghanistan and the Manipur of today. The state has been in turmoil with a complete breakdown in law and order. Instability is the word synonymous to Manipur now. If the idea of liberation is to add to the prevalent upheaval of the state, to disturb the peace of the state, rather than solving the issues and moving towards development then we do not want liberation. We want a place to live in peace and in unison. We are tired of the uncertainty we are in. It is a pity that at the end of the day we find ourselves fighting amongst ourselves for survival.
Everywhere in the country, media enjoys the widely known Freedom of the Press which no one can overrule but in Manipur, media is no longer an autonomous entity. Voicing one’s opinion is more or less like asking for trouble. The people of the state are rotting of poverty, corruption, lack of education, unemployment, etc. What is the use of liberation in such a scenario? When such questions are being posed, the only answer one have is we have rich cultural heritage, we excel in sports, etc… etc. But the rich cultural heritage that we keep bragging about is a thing of the past now. We stand no where near development. And this is an attribution of the brain drain that has been occurring due to the instability of the state, slowing down in the progress of the state. The world, at large, has already gone way up beyond development. And here we are still struggling with Terrorism/Revolution!
The Article was published in Sangai Express on Sunday, 8th January 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
