Twitter Facebook Feed

Some Radical Ideas To Change The State For The Better

“Manipur Still remains a serious insurgency-hit State even though the number of casualties in insurgency-related incidents has gone down… The State of Manipur is yet to achieve peace and tranquility. The insurgent groups in the State are still active and are engaged with the security forces. The forces have achieved quite a considerable success in the past two years but there is still time for the arrival of a lasting peace in the region…” reads the Half Yearly Assessment of the Centre For Development And Peace Studies for the year 2011.

What ails the State of Manipur is the next to nothing Zero economic growth, lack of development, devoid of proper infrastructure and the never-ending list goes on. These have led to the present strife that is prevalent among the different communities in the state. We are, at the moment, going through a very crucial phase. The state is in turmoil and needs immediate attention. The threat on the territorial integrity of the state can never be eradicated completely so long the economic inequality in the state persists. Exploitations, hatreds, jealousy etc will continue to persist, causing tensions, war and disintegration of the state. History is the evidence to the fact that economic inequality is a disease that can turn out to be an epidemic plaguing the society for years with no definite cure. It can lead to exploitation, hatred, distrust, war and disintegration in the society. Hence, the only way to ensure peaceful co-existence and maintain people’s liberty thereby decreasing the misery is by ensuring economic equality. Irrespective of who we are and what we are, we need to collectively work towards evolving different theories to maintain peace in the state.

Religion is another major factor that has led to the drift. A religion based on humanity, sound logic and beneficial experience will be helpful in bringing about the much needed change. All the dogmas, concocted/mythical stories must be casted away and a new religion that preaches progress and prosperity to the humankind must be adopted. It is time to do away with the ideologies of supremacy, false egos, racism etc and move towards practising love, peace and harmony. To avoid the narrow mindedness among the people and to avoid all the activities that have led against the coalition of the people, all kinds of propagations (whether religious, political or social), preaching, rituals etc must be stopped. Let us not forget that religion is from where all the hatreds and indifferences among the people in this world have branched out. Religion is a two-edged knife which, on one hand, preaches us to love and respect one another. On the other hand, it turns us to a religious fanatic compelling us to commit genocides.

Furthermore, the failed condition of Democracy in the State has only added more sufferings to the woes of the people. The ultimate value of democracy is to protect its people and work towards the welfare of the people. Either ways the prevalent situation of democracy in the state is but a name. It is no where close to what Democracy actually stands for. In terms of progress and prosperity, peace and welfare, we need to work collaterally as we are closely knitted geographically. Anything happening in one corner of the state does have an adverse effect on the whole of the state. This, we are well aware of, isn’t it? Whether it s poverty in the hills or the valley, it is a threat to the peace and integrity of the state. This all the more makes it more important for those in power to exercise their duties more appropriately in terms of preventing the failure of the State Machinery and to get rid of all the inequalities prevalent in the state.

In order to work towards for a better future, those living in the valleys as well as the hills must co-operate with one another instead of blaming and accusing each other. For the sake of the economic development of the state, we must now start taking initiatives to make the state stronger. It would be to the best of interest of all the communities and ethnicities to work towards safeguarding one another’s interest. Considering someone living next door as our enemy will only degenerate our own society. It is high time we start to learn to accommodate one another and jointly demand from the government for equal treatment for one and all. Each and every community’s right must be looked after. The government who keeps on flaunting wearing the garb of democracy should start learning their lessons and understand its obligations towards the society as a whole. Shouting for peaceful co-existence and protecting the integrity of the state as if shooting in the dark will not be of much help. It’s high time we act. Or should we continue to wait and watch as a bystander?

Unmistakably The Misunderstood Lot!

Misunderstandings, misapprehensions, delusions, etc have overcome one’s sense of reasoning. No one can claim the know-it-all attitude of the prevalent issues. The problem has been so deep-rooted that it is impossible for anyone to point out what went wrong to try to rectify it. In the previous article that I wrote, many self acclaimed critics took interest in sharing their views. And I truly felt blessed reading their comments as it gave me a better insight on the thought process of the rest of the people. Going through the comments was quite intriguing. At first I thought of replying through the comments but then, on second thought I felt it better to respond it through a write up. And so, here I am, with my arguments and reasoning.

Seriously, the reaction of the readers gave me a better understanding about how our own people consider themselves alien to their own state. But sadly, none of the critics sharing their valuable thoughts understood what was being conveyed through the write up. All I could draw from the comments was everyone understood and weighed the issues keeping in mind only the face value of the situation but none dared to awaken their reasoning selves to address the situation practically. I appreciate those readers who pointed out that the Meitei community started considering other ethnic groups as Manipuri post the June 18 incident only. Fine let us accept that fact but my argument is irrespective of whether the Meitei community considers it or not, no one can deny the fact that all other ethnic groups other than the Meiteis in Manipur are Manipuris. As a matter of fact, I don’t recall any such incident where the Meiteis imposing any such restriction or opposing any ethnic groups from calling themselves Manipuri (Please enlighten me if there were any, I would be obliged). When someone from the mainland asks your identity, do you give the name of your ethnic group? I believe not! Majority of us replies as we are from Manipur and we are Manipuris. So the question of bothering about what other communities think or consider us does not at all arise. We are what we are irrespective of what others think of us and our very existence is the proof of it. The point is as simple as no matter how hard we or the mainlanders deny our identity as an Indian, we are still Indians. And I personally feel that there is no need to remind ourselves of our identity as it only reflects our own inferiority complex which I believe is the root cause of the issues that have branched out today. Now my question is with this kind of mentality do you really think we can come to a practical solution?

Secondly, someone pointed out that if I seriously felt about it then I must come straight to the point and point out mistakes of each one and evaluate instead of beating about the bush. Well, that’s a very profound thought no doubt but what kind of mistakes are you talking about? Are you suggesting that we should recall each and every single incident right from the past and start counting who sinned against whom the greatest? Do you really think that will help us arrive to a solution? I, however, don’t think that is the right approach. What good will it bring digging the past? This doesn’t mean that I am totally denying the fact that Meiteis have wronged to other communities but at the same time, I won’t accept that other communities were righteous. My only point is that let us accept and endorse the fact that every one of us have had our own share of malice and wrong-doings. Let us learn to forget and forgive one another and try to live in peace and harmony to foster unity amongst ourselves. What happened in the past was the result of the segregation that took place during that time. I don’t feel there is the need to point out the incidents where our Kuki brethrens were brutally killed in the name of protecting Naga integrity or the very recent blockade which lasted for 90 days since I feel there is no point dwelling in the past and using it as a weapon to destroy the future. Let us not forget that we are all humans and are prone to make mistakes. Pelting stones at one another will bring no good. And since there are no dearth of stones on each side, I believe, it will further widen the already existing gap among the communities worsening the strife. What will you gain from that? No doubt one might easily denounce their state and severe all ties. But how will you deny the fact that you are a born Manipuri irrespective of your ethnicity?

Last but not the least, I appreciate those who spared there valuable time to share their invaluable thoughts. Your comments and discussions have been a source of great learning experience for me. But those mindless lots who are only good at yapping blatantly and know only how to swear at others should seriously cease their nonsensical talks. You are only adding fuel to the already burning issues. If you cannot think of a better solution then it’s better to remain as a silent spectator. I am not acting as a moral police but simply putting the facts right before you. All I would conclude with is that irrespective of our ethnicity, we belong to a race which could be better referred to as “Unmistakably the misunderstood lot”. The sooner we endorse the fact and try to overcome it, the better it will be and the easier it will be to foster unity among us. We are actually trying to hide in our own shadows. But for how long shall we try to enact something which is not at all possible. It is high time that we overcome our habits of finding faults with one another and work towards finding a middle path. On a positive note, I pray that the April shower washes away all the misunderstandings and differences that prevail among us. Amen!

Perception of The People Towards the Sick State of Affairs!

Not long after the Congress came back to power, the issue of Supra State which has been reframed as an Alternative Arrangement for the Hill People hit the news. Interestingly, the news was followed by the news of an overdraft of Rs 400 Crores which is rather stale news as this is nothing new to Manipur now. However, I am not interested in discussing about these issues at the moment for these issues are nothing new. These were something which, we already knew, would happen sooner or later and by now we ought to have been prepared to face the consequences. However, we were too busy to address the issues well in time as the rumor about the Supra State was suppressed by the hype of the Assembly Elections 2012. The law makers were busy distributing green bucks and the people were busy pocketing the freebies unable to spare much time to pay attention to issues which needed immediate attention. Seeing how things rolled by in the past couple of months prior to the Assembly elections and post Assembly elections, it is not at all surprising to see the state of affairs at such a sorry state. I know there is no need for me to keep talking about these things as we are already aware of it. And since we also know that finding a solution at the moment is next to impossible, we cannot simply jump to a conclusion and wind it up as we wish for it is a very sensitive issue. Yet again, we cannot simply ignore the situation and leave it as it is till the right time strides in. Among the various reasons responsible for the situation we are in right now, one major contributing factor is our short-sightedness.

Anyway, I am more interested in talking about the reaction/perception of our own people, the Manipuris to be precise, which includes all sections of the society irrespective of caste, creed, religion and ethnicity towards the sick state of affairs. It is heart rending to see the way they reacted to the news. The comments given to the article shot up beyond 50 but sadly, very few among those who commented in the article expressed genuine concerned about the prevalent scenario. This reflects the pathetic situation we are in. It is the high time we realize the fact that irrespective of being a Naga, Meitei, Kuki or any other ethnic group, we are all Manipuris and we can never denounce this fact no matter how hard we try. We are all sailing in the same boat going through rough times together trying to survive. And in such a crucial stage where we should be shouldering one another, it is a pity that we are trying to cut each other’s throat. The allegations and profanities that we throw at each other isn’t going to bring about an amicable solution. What makes it so difficult for us to understand and accept the fact that this will only lead to creating further rift among the communities giving way to enmity and bloodsheds? What will we gain from it? Only the downtrodden and common people who know nothing will shed their blood in the name of ‘SACRIFICE’. And those in power will take full advantage of the situation. Irrespective of their ethnicity, those who shed their blood are the wisest fools or blatant losers. Those in power will come to an agreement and survive in harmony. This is what Politics is all about!So, why should we resort to shed one’s blood when giving life to someone is beyond our powers?

Our actions speak of our perceptions and this can either deteriorate or improve a situation. Our thoughts, discernments and actions all influence the surrounding around us and have a direct impact on our lives. Reading the responses to the article, “Delhi toys with idea of maximum autonomy with administrative and financial control in lieu of Lim model Naga solution: ‘Supra State’ likely to don a new avatar”, dated 6th of April 2012. I am left with no choice but to presume that except for a handful lots, majority of the people are mindless and do not understand the gravity of the situation we are in. What the GOI is doing is simply taking advantage of our situation and we are foolishly letting them have what they want. Like one of the comments in the article which read as, ‘what the GOI is doing is simply trying to convert a National Issue to a Regional Issue’, the GOI is indeed toying with our sentiments. And consciously or unconsciously, we are making it easier for the Politicians by dancing in their tunes. Why should we let ourselves be treated as a puppet? Why should we always look up to the Centre and depend on them for every little thing we need? If we wish to then there are many things that can be done. We can build the sovereignty of our state by ourselves. Unity among us is what it takes to materialize it. Trust me, just a little effort from our part is all it takes to reform our ill-gotten society. How much does it cost you to unite and foster harmony? I bet not even a dime!

“He is the Of Manipur With little Knowledge of Development”

The other day I happened to search the Internet with the Keyword, “O. Ibobi. Singh” and what I found in the search result was rather astounding. I bumped into Wikipedia with a page on Shri O. Ibobi Singh. At the first glance, I felt proud thinking that finally our honorable Chief Minister has also made it to the internet. But as I went through over what was written I found the concluding line hilarious which read as, “He is the Of Manipur With little Knowledge of Development” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Okram_Ibobi_Singh). It is not the error in the sentence that made me pass a wry smile but the comment in the statement. I am well aware that the sentence in itself is incomplete. And I have deliberately copy-pasted the line without rectifying the mistake from Wikipedia. The instant I read it, the first thought that crossed my mind was, ‘What a joke!’ But come to think of it, I realized that there was nothing profound which would actually negate the statement. And it is a pity that the CM of Manipur has been portrayed in such a dim light despite making his way for the third term in power after having been in power for two consecutive terms. I believe most of the people who know how to access the internet must have surely come across the page some way or the other but none of us bothered to rectify it. This simply shows how much we loathe him and I presume that the reasons that support the bitterness towards him are more than justified.

If you recall, it was during his regime that the three month long blockade took place wherein the lifeline of the state was completely cut off. And during that crucial time, our honorable CM of Manipur, instead of trying to stabilize the situation of the state, was actually planning a tour to Europe to make an escapade leaving the people and their state to its own fate. But what luck! Our poor CM had to give up his tour to Europe. All this occurred prior to the Assembly Election 2012. And the incident itself spoke out loud enough for the deaf to hear and the dumb to speak for their own. All said and done, despite all the visible flaws during his reign, Okram Ibobi still managed to make a clean sweep in the Assembly election 2012. The incident of the three month long blockade was an eye-opener for the people of Manipur to reflect their own mistakes but sadly, we plunged into making the same old mistakes once again as if what we have been going through is not more than enough. And the result of being blind-folded by a couple of green bucks is now what we see in the form of potholes on the roads, limited power supply of 4 hours, increased traffic congestions, continuous delay in salaries etc. All thanks to our honorable Chief Minister O. Ibobi’s over-sightedness.

The price of the essential commodities had sky-rocketed during the three month long blockade, and till date, decrease in the price to normal rates is a far cry. Those in power are mum and are enjoying the sight whereas those suffering and struggling to meet the high cost of living seem to have accepted it as their fate instead of decrying foul and raising their voice against the lootings that have been taking place in the name of selling essential commodities. Have you ever heard of any place in the country where LPG gas is being sold at Rs 1800/-, petrol at Rs 180 per liter and other commodities at a price much higher than its actual cost? I am still amazed at the attitude of the people in the state who still manage to afford instead of protesting against it.

Secondly, Manipur has been reeling under terror since time immemorial. Sometimes it is the fear of those clad in khaki, at times from unwanted elements and most of the time from the unpredictable situation of the state. You never know when a shootout or a bomb blast will take place. Our whole life has been engulfed in fear. From the moment we walk out of our home till the time we come back safe and sound at home, no one can be sure of how the day will turn out to be. It’s like walking with our hearts in our hands. With the Government coming into power for the third time, the insecurity seemed to have increased manifold. Crimes in the state have increased inimitably. Manipur, which was once considered a safe haven for women, has today become a place were minors and women are raped. The rampant scenario in the state only reflects the ineptitude of the state government and the loss of morality among the youth of Manipur. It is high time them that appropriate measures be taken by the people as well as the state to curb the situation.

We take pride in declaring ourselves as the educated lots who look forward to bringing about a major change for a better future. But why are we acting and behaving dumb in situations such as these? Or are we seriously dumber than the dumb? All we know is to blame and point fingers towards others. Why do we always think that others will dirty their hands to clean up our mess? Unless we stand up and speak for our own, no one will stand up for us. This is what we were taught when in school but we seem to have forgotten the moral values we learnt in our childhood. Although we teach our children and siblings to be righteous, we have actually forgotten to put our own words into action. If those in power have forgotten their duties towards its people and the state then it is our duty as a responsible citizen to make them accountable for it and to keep them in check so that such mistakes do not happen twice. They say, “Action speaks louder than word”, so why not we try to foster the saying just once for the sake of a better future? Our state is already in a vulnerable condition. If we do not unite and stand up against the odds to curb it then who will? Or do you still wish to rot in the present situation and watch Manipur being reduced to a deplorable situation? Do you want people around the globe to refer to the state as a state ruled by someone “With little Knowledge of Development” as has been stated in Wikipedia? Choice is yours!

Let’s Make Manipur A Better Place To Live In

Politics, politics, politics! Day in and day out, all we care to talk about is politics. All we know is to curse the goddamn system and those in power. But, how politically conscious are we? How responsible are we when it comes to practicing our right? There are 3-4 things that always come in the picture the moment the word ‘Manipur’ is uttered. Yes, you got it right! It is politics, corruption, insurgency (which most people in the mainland read it as terrorism or naxalites), organized crimes and poverty. It is said that a democracy stands on four pillars viz. Legislature, Executive, Judiciary and Press. However, the foundation of democracy in Manipur lies on the pillars of Corruption, Insurgency, Organized crimes and Poverty. If we happen to hold a debate, group discussion, a talk show or an essay competition on the topic, ‘Manipur democracy and its universality’, most of the discussions or debates will talk about nothing else but the above mentioned pillars of democracy pertaining to our state. We speak of freedom, communal harmony, right to live, equality, so on and so forth, but with the kind of pillars that our state democracy rests on, I think it is a far cry. Unless the system of democracy in our state rests on the actual four pillars of democracy, bringing a change in the system is what should be termed as next to impossible. Yet, we cannot give up our hopes that Manipur will change for the better some day with worthy leaders holding the rein of the state and more responsible citizens.

Many refer to the state of Manipur as the failed state or the forgotten state of India. Scanning through the local dailies, all we get to read about is the local politics and people killed in a shootout or an ambush. Unless a major event (something which is usually termed as a ghastly incident) occurs, Manipur fails to find a space in the National papers. Before the newspaper for tomorrow is printed, we can easily predict what all the newspaper will carry the next day. Deaths and more deaths of innocent civilians will cover the major part of the paper. A news article in the Telegraph reported, ‘Poverty increases in Manipur’ (I cannot recall the exact headlines, so please bear with me). But do you really think Poverty in Manipur has actually increased? I doubt it. Though it might have increased in black and white but if we analyze keeping in mind the actual scenario, I think the report is a distorted truth. Suppose there is a job opening under the State Government, what do you think will happen? Everyone will run hither-thither to collect the amount that has to be handed over under the table. My point is, if poverty has increased in money, from where will this money come to pay for the job? Secondly, no one will question your eligibility for the position as money matters come in first. Whether one is qualified for the position or not, if you pay for it then the job will be undoubtedly yours. Who do you think is actually responsible for the occurrence of such a thing? We blame the system and those in power every time. But isn’t it, actually, us who have made the system that way? Aren’t we the ones who have taught those in power that we are ready to be trampled by them? And yet we blame the Government for being corrupt when it is us who made our own Government corrupt. Let us assume for an instant that every single soul in Manipur vows to cease bribing the Government for any position in the system. Do you think the Government will suspend the recruitment declaring that no eligible candidate turned up for the said position? I don’t know about the rest but at least I find it hard to believe.

Someone known to me once said, when I asked about Manipur, “Manipur haiba lam se leiheidre, mawong marin tadre, paisa paibana pung paida pai, paidabana chaokhatpa suk ngam ngamde, angam angam chathoknaro haiba do toure”. It is very discouraging and frustrating to see the sigh of despair and to hear the lament. But I hope that this time a new dawn will don. Now that Shri O.Ibobi has made a comeback again for the third time, all our hopes are glued towards him. I wish to believe that this time the Government will let bygones be bygones and make a new move that will at least lead to a new day for the state and its people. We learn from our mistakes and as they experience are our greatest teachers, I hope, our honorable Chief Minister will rectify or at least try to rectify those things that have gone wrong. It is said to break down a wall one blow is not enough. However, what we are looking forward to is not to break down the wall instantly. All we ask for is the effort to make that ‘One Blow’ that will lead to many blows that will sow the seeds of a brighter Manipur. I wish to appeal, to one and all, to jointly make an effort and strive together to make Manipur a better place to live in.

The Inimitable March Wind Passing By Amidst The End Of The World Saga…

Come March and the festive season marks the beginning of the spring season with all its mirth. Holi or Yaoshang as it is popularly known in Manipur has its own taste and flavor. Amidst the exam fever and the hullabaloo of the election fiesta, the spirit of Yaoshang is still high. As predicted, the year 2012, seems to be a year of prosperity, growth and harmony. Exhibiting a bright year ahead, the month of March saw the onset of Vasant Utsav. Blended with the colors of hope, peace, harmony and prosperity, the spring season was welcomed colorfully. One may ask what is so special about the spring season of this year and what makes it different from those of the yesteryears. Considering the face value, one might fail to notice much of a difference. However, if you sit down to think about it then, there are many things that will come to your notice.

The year 2012, according to the Chinese Astrology, is the year of the Water Dragon which will prove to be awe-inspiring. The year of the dragon, as it is commonly known, is believed to be one of the most fortunate years for marriage, new babies and new business ventures. Although, most of the people would prefer to bite their tongue than to acknowledge it, most of the parents hold a serious belief in it and plan the marriage of their children so that it coincide with the dragon year. In short, the year 2012, is a year for rejoicing, merriment and gaiety for the Chinese. While the Asian countries are busy preparing to rejoice the year 2012, the Western world is gripped in fear with doubts regarding the Doomsday! December 21st, 2012, is the day which most people belonging to the other part of the world believe to be the Day of Judgment. It might sound absurd to most of us but the day is considered to be the day the world will finally come to an end. And the sole reason behind it is the end of the Mayan Calender. Many foreseers have drawn different views about it. Irrespective of the views, all that we can be sure of is that the world coming to an end on December 21st, 2012, is the last thing that will ever happen. This is the least that we would ever want to believe and dismiss it as a “ridiculous hype”.

As a matter of fact, the period that we are going through right now is believed to be a period of transition. Punch in the keyword, ‘21st December, 2012’ or ‘end of the world’ and browse through the internet. You will be amazed with the discussions, articles and blogs listed in the search engine within the blink of an eye. Many hold a strong belief that an Apocalypse is all set to occur. There is no doubt that the catastrophe that still worries the superstitious self has been dismissed as a fluke. However, the year is believed to be a year that will give birth to a New World order, which is on the verge of evolution. The year will be the beginning of a World that will propagate a higher level of consciousness, communal harmony which will preach humanism and equality. Whether it is a fluke or hype, it hardly matters but what actually counts is the evolution of a New World Order.

However, do any of these hypes affect us or influence us in anyway? As far as I am concerned, I am least bothered about it and hope the same for the rest as well. But yes, I longed for the New World Order to develop and the rest of you do share the same feeling. With our respected Chief Minister, Shri O. Ibobi all set to make his grand entry for the third consecutive term, creating a landmark in the history of Manipur, who cares about the hype. When our own home has been strife- ridden for ages, do we have the time to bother about an issue as silly as this? Amidst the gala political tussle, we are all caught up with the colors of Yaoshang, Thabal Chongba, the forthcoming Cheiraoba and many other festivities that are on the pipeline. While the inimitable March wind is passing by gently and before it turns violent manifest the end of the world saga, let us all gear up and make the most of this festive season.

Let us all live up to the true essence of Yaoshang and with our fingers crossed, let us all pray that this spring sows the seeds for a better future that will foster prosperity, peace and harmony in the state. With the Yaoshang thabal, let us preach and practice the spirit of brotherhood and communal harmony. Let this year be a year that will go into the history of Manipur as the ‘Golden Year’ for the future of Manipur. Let’s keep the spirit alive and kicking. Amen!

On The Eviction Of The Candidates Of The Board Exam’12

With the onset of the exam season, the fate of 7000 students have been sealed guaranteeing the loss of a complete one year. The newspaper read loud and clear, “BOSEM invalidates candidature of 7000 students opting for hill centres” on the 23 of February 2012. I bet the news was made to raise the eyebrows of many. But, I feel that it is no news at all for we all know this was coming though it came much later than expected! Malpractices during/in examination are nothing new. This has been an ongoing affair everywhere in the world but more particularly in India. However, as compared to the rest of the country, the education scenario in Manipur has gone from bad to worse. History is the evidence of how the exam season is more like a ceremonious event celebrating with friends and family rather than taking exams to decide the future of the students.

“Khongban chenba” is a term which evolved out of it referring to the friends and family members of the candidate who are gathered in the school to supply the materials to the student. Mass copying, using unfair means during examination, etc is a common practice in Manipur. Although the practice had been curbed to some extent due to the intervention of some organizations, one has to go a long way to clean the system of examination. Canceling the candidatures of the students, out of the blue, that too when the examination is round the corner, is not the solution for the problem. No doubt quality education is what should be sought but not at the cost of the future of 7000 students. Why should the students bear the brunt of the mistakes of BOSEM? The incident only presents the flaws of the education system in Manipur and the worthlessness of those heading the institution. What were the concerned authorities doing when the students enrolled themselves for the examination? Should the students or parents be held responsible for it?

No doubt education is the foundation for the welfare of a state but the approach BOSEM has adopted this year is something that can be termed as outrageous. I would, in fact, presume that the deed was done to cover up themselves but unfortunately or fortunately, it has reflected the deteriorating education system in Manipur highlighting their own inaccuracies and inabilities. Strongly condemning the attitude of the authorities responsible for the eviction of the students, I would say it would have been better if they had tried to delve deeper into the issue rather than hushing up things by evicting those 7000 students. The reason behind why such a large number of students wished to sit for their exams in the hill centres is well understood by all and sundry. It goes without saying that the lack of proper invigilator at the exam centers, proper inspection during the exams lead to clearing the exams easily. So why did not the concerned authorities resort to finding a solution that would answer the immediate need? Where the eligibility of the students sitting for the exam is concerned, the authorities should have verified it a couple of months ago when the examination forms had been filled. We are normally instructed to fill the forms and submit it 4-5 months prior to the commencement of the exams. This I believe is done so that all the required verifications could be done beforehand so that the concerned candidates may submit the required documents well in time. But in the prevalent scenario, this was the least that could have been done by the authorities.

It would have been much better, if the authorities had adopted a more reasonable approach. Instead of evicting the students from taking their exams, the invigilators could have employed more teachers or engage temporary invigilators for the hill centres. Even if there are limited teachers (I believe there are no dearth of teachers in Manipur), then the authorities could have hired temporary teachers from amongst the students pursuing their interns or researching. In some other states, I have seen this approach being adopted when they run short of invigilators for the examination. So, if this can be adopted in other states then why can’t we? Although this may not be a long term solution but the students might have had an opportunity to sit for the exams this year. The students might not have had to go through the psychological abuse. I do not guarantee that all the 7000 students would make it through the exams and become great doctors, engineers or politicians, but even if they had failed, they would have realized that it was due to their lack of sincere effort. And this might have encouraged the students to work harder for the next session. It is said “ninth-tenth of education is encouragement” but the implication of the proverb is very bleak here in our state.

I am not, in anyway, implying that the students should be encouraged to use unfair means. However, I won’t deny that steps taken up by BOSEM have gone beyond any extremities. The purpose of an educationist is to help students create their own image. It is a much clichéd saying that young students are like mud and they can be molded in any shape and size. It is during this formative stage that a true educationist should instill good ideas and thoughts to these young minds. No doubt, they should be reprimanded for their mistakes. However, they should not be punished in such a manner that their future and career may be tainted. Let us not forget that by doing so we are actually compelling them to become a part of the unwanted elements of the society.

Identity Crisis - The Struggle To Come With Terms

Numerous upheavals have been experienced by the people of Manipur irrespective of their ethnicity. Ever since the advent of Hinduism in Manipur, clashes among different cultures and ethnic groups have been witnessed by the State. A series of epoch making encounters have taken place over the centuries which have only led to widening the gap among the people of the Manipur on the basis of communalism and ethnicity. Digging into past, traces of Hinduism can be seen since the 17th Century i.e. during the reign of King Charairongba. However, it was only after the ascension of King Pamheiba that the imposition of Hinduism swept across the State. This gave way to the evolution of two traditional culture and worldviews, which only led to further widening the gap. Thus, the ancient Asiatic land of Manipur experienced a major change. There were, no doubt various other factors leading to this major change however, the seed of confusion was sown with the advent of Hinduism in Manipur.

The cultural onslaught that took place in the 18th century with the burning of the Meitei scriptures during the reign of King Garibiniwaz during the conversion of Meiteis into Bengali Vaishnavism led to the transmutation of the original culture. The conversion and the transformation had a major influence in the Meitei Mayek. The elimination of the society’s identity, its traditional belief and culture were viciously subdued. New words were introduced into the Manipuri vocabulary and Bengali script replaced Meitei Mayek, the indigenous script. The Meitei script that nearly became extinct is now available in three forms. One form of Meitei Mayek consists of 18 characters only out of which 15 were consonant characters and 3 characters were pure vowels. The second form of Meitei Mayek consists of 27 characters, which was initiated by Naorem Phumdrei and is known as the Naoriya mayek. The third form is said to consist of 36 characters. Tracing the origin of Meitei Mayek would be a next to impossible task. However, the earliest use of the script is found to have recorded in the early 11 and 12th AD.




As a matter of fact, Meiteilon as stated by Dr. Irengbam Mohendra Singh, in his article, “The origin of the Meitei language”, is a ‘language isolate’ i.e which has no proven relationship with any other living language (until proven otherwise). It has not descended (cognate) from Tibeto-Burman (TB) languages, but has ‘language affinities’ with some i.e. similar in some structure that may suggest a common origin. There is no evidence that it has taken any leaf out of the books of neighboring languages. It has no known common ancestry with any other language. Nor are there any available facts that it has been borrowed from any other language.

Language is the epitome of holding societies together and it is one of the most important components that relates to the ethnic politics. During those periods, only the clans of the Kings were referred to as the Meiteis as they belong to the ruling class. Later on, the principle of the ethnonym “Meitei” restricted to the clans of the Kings was overruled and people from different social groups were absorbed to form a new ethnic group called “Meiteis”, which today populates the valley. The religion of the Meiteis constitutes its own myths and legends, rituals and festivals, and it was, nevertheless more or less akin to the animism of the tribals. Back then, caste stratification was something unknown to the Manipuri society and marriage outside one’s clan or tribe existed in those days.

So far, all that I can presume is, Manipur, before the sanskritization took place, when only Sanamahism existed, was bound by its own faiths and beliefs. There wasn’t much difference in the practice of rituals. Even today, the festival of Lai Haraoba is considered as incomplete if our tribal brothers are not present in the festival. Despite the difference in language and ethnicity, all the people of Manipur irrespective of whether they belong to the hills or the valley, was bound by a common faith. The eating habits were similar, preparing rice beer was a common practice in every household. Even the language spoken back then was similar to some extent.

Later on, after Sanskritization, an intrusion that created a wide rift between the ethnicity of the people of the valley and the hills in the name of religion took place. The rift of the conversion slithered so deep that today, it has taken the shape of communal hatred. Besides this, the introduction of caste system in the meitei society further contributed to separation. Lois and yaithibis are the set of people who have been regarded as the low caste which otherwise belonged to the same caste. Before the advent of Hinduism, there was no caste system in Meitei society. However, lois still existed in the said period. Lois were people who were exiled by the Meitei kings to far flung places for various reasons. Today, all of us are suffering from identity crisis and we are still struggling to come with terms.

Assembly Election 2012: A Curtain Raiser Or Not?

The show is over, the deed is done. Despite the recommendation and strict vigil of the Election Commissioner and the Security Forces, the politicians managed to have their way. They were so adamant and forceful in their effort to woo the voters that they finally did it! How I wish they would be as enthusiastic as they are once they come to power to hold the reigns. Rumours about the election have been making its rounds across the state. Some says the result is already known and they are waiting for the judgment day just for the sake of waiting. Some still wait with their fingers crossed for the results of the election that will be declared in the month of March. But all said and done, the response of the public at large is what amuses me.

Though I wasn’t personally there to watch the furor and the humor but I felt a tickle hearing my friends out who took part in the election. There were people with all sorts of mentalities making the most of the opportune moment. Some getting over-excited about the 500 and 1000 rupees notes literally walking up to their door steps. It seemed as if it was raining green papers. On a lighter note, don’t you think it would be fun seeing all those Gandhi yekpa notes literally walking around in the streets! As always, people would go crazy like they had gone crazy on the eve of the election. The power of money is indeed amazing.

Amidst the mayhem and the hype that ripped the city before the elections, a friend told me about a group of like-minded people/youngsters from the Hatta locality who gathered together and resolved to not accept anything in lieu of their votes. They even went a step ahead by presenting a list which recorded their names to every candidate contesting from their Kendra. Although I am not very sure of the veracity of this information, I would simply say “Hats Off To Their Spirit”. It might not have made much of a difference, it is just the beginning. Today, there were just a handful of them, tomorrow there would be another lots joining them and then another lots will join in leading to the redemption and resurrection of a new Manipur.

No one is sure of whether the Assembly Election 2012 will raise the curtain or not but one thing is certain and that is the shortsightedness of the public. How they can be blinded by a few bucks to forsake everything is inexplicably incomprehensible. All they could see is the money they get in the form of, call it, a bribe which in actual is synonymous to selling themselves. For years, it has been going on, yet no one is ready to acknowledge it as an unbeatable crime. They consider it as a righteous act. And the result is right before us. As always, another corrupt Government is in the making, which will be followed by a series of hues and cries about bills not being passed, salary being delayed, increase of potholes on the roads, power cuts becoming more frequent and so on and so forth!

What is the point of raising such hue and cries when you have actually become a part of the corrupt government? The 28th of January 2012 was a day that could have changed the future of the state, if the public at large have acted responsibly. However, passing a comment on it, when the results are yet to come, would be unfair. So, at the moment, all we can do is just wait and watch! But we all know that the fate of Manipur has already been sealed and as of now, nothing much can be done about it. Whatever may be the result, let’s just hope that everything turns out well and fare good at least for the future of the state. Even if it does not turn out to be as good as we expected then we should not be cursing or blaming anyone but ourselves. For, it was we who preferred to turn a blind eye because of our greed.

Let us instead learn our lessons this time and make a joint effort to sensitize one another about the importance of vote and the significance of choosing the right candidate who can represent us and act on our behalf. Beyond politics, the need of the hour is to educate the people and make them understand the value of their votes. Instead of totaling the burden of the state, let us just do our bit and share our knowledge to make the people aware of the grave mistake they have made. Irrespective of whether the Assembly Election 2012 proves to be a curtain raiser or not, let us make it an eye opener for the future.

It’s Time To Decide Our Destiny!

Trying to make some sense by nitpicking from all the nonsense is, indeed, quite a task. There are a hell lot of things on which one can think and write about. However, I seriously feel there is no point writing on the issues any more for, even the intellectuals have chosen to blindfold their eyes. And in such a situation, what can we supposedly do rather than beating about the bush. The need of the hour is to strike the iron when it is hot but we are all caught up in the hustle and bustle of election. Do you seriously think the election is worth it? I personally feel that the election has little meaning entitled to itself, as democracy makes no sense at all in our society. The term, "Democracy" itself sounds good to hear but in reality, keeping the prevailing situation in the state in mind, it is but a term which means the opposite of its actual definition.



The same kind of people wearing different garbs might come to power making vague promises, which will never be fulfilled. After the elections are over, the same people who had shown us hope for peaceful survival will go back to their comfortable cocoons. And this is a fact which all of us are aware of. Deep down inside, we all know that those who will come to power will work towards fostering only their interest forgetting all about the interest of the state and the public. As usual, history will repeat itself. Like the years that have gone by, Manipur will again witness a series of crisis and the public will be caught between the devil and the deep sea, not knowing whom to turn to. The same issues regarding electricity, bandhs, blockades, disruption in education will continue to persist unscathed. Some things that will certainly change are the frequency of economic blockades, bomb blasts and atrocities towards the helpless public. In such a scenario, does ‘Democracy’ really make sense?

The day is not far when Manipur will be known throughout the world as the one and only tiny state nestled in the corner of the country called India where corruption, terrorism, poverty and backwardness are the four pillars of the state. So, should we continue to wait with our hands tight till that day comes? Should we cast our valuable votes just for the sake of some green notes and instant pleasures that do not last long? Don’t you think, by doing so, you are putting your future at stake? Instead of getting carried away by the false promises and leaving the future of the state at the hands of the wrong people, it would be better to boycott the election. The furor of the election is at its peak and amidst the hype, the lucid self will have no say. Even if it does, the covetous self will suppress and silence it without giving it a chance to make itself heard. Why not we try to change history once and for all? Why not we unite for once and raise our voices against the imposters who have always misused the power entrusted to them by the public and mislead our future?

The system itself is dirty and those people in the system instead of dirtying their hands to clean the system, jump into the dirt and turn out to be dirtier than the system itself. I have heard somewhere that, “If you want to change the system, you must be in the system”. However, in Manipur, it seems to be the other way round. Those in power justify themselves and dismiss with the view that all institutions are prone to corruption and to the vices of their members. To woo the public, the candidates and their respective political parties have drawn a series of issues to be addressed in their manifestoes. However, have they ever provided a feasible approach or strategy before the public as to how they will curb the present scenario? Instead of listening silently like a mute spectator to their public speeches, have you ever thought of counter questioning their manifestations? Just a brief mention about addressing the social issues without any practical solution at hand should not lure us or appease us to think that the said candidates will put in their heart and soul to maneuver progress in the state.

This article is nothing but an outburst of pent up emotions of a simple person who is caught between the ‘Power’ and the ‘Terror’ but still optimistic that the dark cloud of hopelessness will soon vanish into thin air. Sooner than later, we will be blessed with a new dawn of hope, peace and prosperity. The time to materialize the dream is not far away if we, the public, realize our duties, responsibilities and authority in regard to the election that is just a couple of hours away. The Assembly Election 2012 is actually a wake up call for all of us to wake up from the deep slumber and make the right choice for the future and for a better Manipur. So value your votes, and if you must vote then, select the right candidate who can and will materialize all the agendas being put forth in their manifesto. Or else boycott the election instead of voting for the sake of a few hundred bucks. Though this might be a short-term goal, but for the time being, I personally feel, there is no other better option than this. As this is one of the best methods that can be adopted to make the politicians realize and be compelled to do something solid for the state instead of hurling bombs and grenades which only causes loss to the state. It is we, the public, who can actually make a difference and not those in power! Now is the time to act in order to live a life of dignity and well-being. Let's decide and carve our destiny this time.